Thursday, February 11, 2010

Cake Eaters: Voting Now Closed

This was a lot of fun! I'm so grateful to those gals who entered and I was really impressed with all the different ideas everyone had. Take a gander at what everyone came up with and please vote (details below). The more the merrier!


Entry #1 The Walnut Tree



Entry #2 The Memorial Garden



Entry #3 Special Box



Entry #4 Stained Glass Window



Entry #5 Dark Divine Chocolate Surprise



To Vote:
Leave a comment stating which cake you like the best (either by entry number or description).

Fine print:
Voting will be open to the everyone until Saturday at 2pm MST.
All cakes will remain anonymous until the winners are announced Saturday Feb 13th 2009.

54 comments:

aprilnichole said...

entry #1

Crystal said...

Entry 1

but 4 is pretty cool too

Kristina P. said...

#4

Amy said...

#1

Rebecca Talley said...

#4

Olivia Carter said...

#4 all the way. How do they do that?

Son of a Didlee said...

Entry #4 Stained Glass Window
I liked them all, but I really enjoyed the simple but realistic aproach

Heather Justesen said...

I'm not going to vote since I have an entry, but I wanted to say great work everyone--very cool ideas I never thought of. =)

Noble M Standing said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
TOWR said...

#4

E.A. West said...

They're all cool, but I have to vote for Entry #4

Poohbar said...

I am a fan for the Walnut Tree, cake #1. It could be all about my penchant for purple, but that's my choice at any rate!

cynthial11 said...

I love #4, it's beautiful!

Forever Friends said...

I liked the Dark Chocalate Surprise, but have to vote f or #4 the Stained Glass Window, mainly because the father in Nicholas Spark's The Last Song is making a Stained Glass Window for a Church and I love stained glass windows.

Catie S (Book Bound) said...

#4 is my favorite. Followed closely by #1

Danyelle Ferguson said...

I'm voting for #4. The Stained Glass is gorgeous!

I also really liked the purple layers in the Dark Divine Chocolate Surprise. They're awesome!

Valerie Ipson said...

They're all nice, but I'll vote for number 4.

Emily said...

#4

BrittLit said...

I love #1 although I do enjoy #5 too. #1 is just such a recognizable symbol that really represents the book.

Kimberly Job said...

My vote is for the stained glass cake.

The Crockett Family said...

They all look DELISH! Number 4 is my fave though! Closely followed by Number 1

Connie Hall said...

My vote is for #4. All of them are well done.

Gail Pallotta said...

It's between Dark Divine Chocolate Surprise and Stained Glass Window.
They all look so good. They're making me hungry.

Susan said...

I like the stained glass one, and I loved the inside of the chocolate surprise one. Very cool.

EriKa said...

#5, just cuz

Read To Review said...

#4 is my favorite. They are all great but there is just something about the stain glass look

Stacey said...

#4 is my vote!!

all 6 is great though, congrats to all the entrants!

Andrea said...

Now I'm craving cake. =) They all look so amazing. Good job, everyone!

My vote is for Entry #1.

Nichole Giles said...

While I agree that the stained glass is definitely cool...I'm going to be a rebel and vote for number 2. If that thing is hand sculpted, well, that's incredible. And with the stakes around the sides, I tend to think it's hand done.

If it's plastic, not so much. But I'm believing it's edible at this point.

Luisa said...

The stained glass has to take the cake. Nice job to the others, but that one is just awesome!

Jenilyn said...

#5 is my favorite, although it's really close with all of them!

Jenilyn said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
L.T. Elliot said...

I vote for cake #1. It's creepy and beautiful! =]

Elise said...

#1

Erin said...

#1

Elie said...

Wow, they are all incredible. If I must choose one I will say...
#4

Kristie said...

#5, cause I really want a piece! It looks so yummy!

Susan P. said...

#1! Says it all.

Rachel@MyPinkFlipFlops said...

Number 1 the tree.

Jenni Elyse said...

I like #1 the best. I think they're all great, though. My next favorite is the chocolate surprise. I love this book just because of all the purpleness!

Jenni Elyse said...

PS - I want to know if they taste as good as they look!

Jenn Wilks said...

I feel a little bad entering this contest in a way because 1-I haven't read the book yet, so I don't even know which one might represent the book best. And 2-They're all so amazing! I feel like I'm voting /against/ 4 awesome cakes! :o(

I'm pretty sure Nichole is right about #2 - when you look at the full-size version, you can see thumb prints in the angel's wings. I'm pretty sure that's hand-carved.

However, I'm going to have to vote for #4, just because it took my breath away when I saw it.

Great job everyone, though!!

Vicki said...

I think they are all great, but if I have to vote, I'll go for #4.

Shauna said...

My vote goes to #1!!! ...Closely followed by #4 & #3! Awesome cakes guys!!

Danielle Thorne said...

I vote for #1. Very neat.

Brie said...

I'd have to say #4. It's beautiful and so creative.

Suzanne said...

As for decorating #4, but I love #5inside. They are all amazing.

Variety said...

Difficult, it's a toss up between #1 and #4. They're both beautiful, but I'm especially impressed by the round cake (shape), so my final vote has to go to #1.

Mary Campbell said...

Wow - all those cakes are so cool. I think I like entry #4 the most. That stained glass is awesome.

Rita A. said...

Love #4 Awesome job on all the cakes.

Shelley said...

I love Cake #1, but have to vote for the stained glass #4. How was that even done? BTW, we're going to read Dark Divine in Bookclub due to the fabulous Variety - YAY!

Violet said...

They are all gorgeous, but I can't resist the purple loveliness of #1! :)

greeniejoey said...

love #5

MEME said...

#1 because I could never make a tree look that good!